Reviewer Guidelines

Reviewers should provide independent, constructive, evidence-based, and timely assessments.

Reviews should evaluate:

• Relevance to the journal
• Originality and contribution
• Theoretical grounding
• Methodological rigor
• Quality of analysis
• Interpretation of results
• Clarity and organization
• Ethical and reporting standards

Comments should help editors make informed decisions and help authors improve their work. Reviewers should avoid hostile, personal, discriminatory, or unsupported comments.